Chris Packham wades into ‘glorious 12th’ grouse shooting row

Springwatch’s Chris Packham wades into ‘glorious 12th’ grouse shooting row by tweeting photo of Golden Eagle ‘crippled and dying’ with trap dangling from legs near Balmoral estate

  • Chris Packham has called for an end to the grouse shooting in Twitter post
  • Wildlife expert posted an image of a Golden Eagle flying with a trap on its leg 
  • It comes amid call by Labour to review grouse shooting over environmental fears
  • The party want consideration to be given to ‘viable alternatives’ like wildlife tourism 

TV wildlife expert Chris Packham has waded into the row over grouse shooting by tweeting a photo of a Golden Eagle flying with a trap on its leg.

The BBC Springwatch host posted the shocking image online with a link to a petition calling for a ban on the practice just days after the so-called ‘Glorious Twelfth’ when the four month long season began.

This year Labour is calling for a review of grouse shooting amid warnings it causes substantial environmental damage to important natural habitats.

The party has said consideration should also be given to ‘viable alternatives’ such as simulated shooting or wildlife tourism.

Today Packham uploaded the image of the rare bird after it was spotted flying over the Crathie area of Deeside, Aberdeenshire on August 8, near the Queen’s Balmoral estate.

Mr Packham tweeted celebrities including comedians Ricky Gervias, Frankie Boyle, Sue Perkins and Dragon’s Den star Deborah Meaden and wrote underneath the picture: ‘Look at this Golden Eagle crippled and dying with a trap dangling from its legs.

Chris Packham has waded into the row over grouse shooting by tweeting this photo of a Golden Eagle flying with a trap on its leg

Chris Packham has waded into the row over grouse shooting by tweeting this photo of a Golden Eagle flying with a trap on its leg

Mr Packham tweeted celebrities including comedians Ricky Gervias, Frankie Boyle, Sue Perkins and Dragon's Den star Deborah Meaden and wrote underneath the picture: 'Look at this Golden Eagle crippled and dying with a trap dangling from its legs

Mr Packham tweeted celebrities including comedians Ricky Gervias, Frankie Boyle, Sue Perkins and Dragon’s Den star Deborah Meaden and wrote underneath the picture: ‘Look at this Golden Eagle crippled and dying with a trap dangling from its legs

‘Please ask your followers to sign this petition to ban driven grouse shooting.’

It is unclear what the link is between the image of the bird with a trap on its legs and the practice of grouse shooting. 

The Golden Eagle has protected status under the Wildlife and Countryside Act 1981 and is classified as an amber-list species under the Birds of Conservation Concern review. 

Speaking to Channel 4 News yesterday, Packham said it was what he called ‘driven grouse shooting’ the sport of shooting red grouse, that he wants banned.

He said: ‘It is enormously and environmentally destructive, and is also extremely destructive when it comes to our wildlife

Speaking to Channel 4 News yesterday, Packham (pictured) said it was what he called 'driven grouse shooting' the sport of shooting red grouse, that he wants banned

Speaking to Channel 4 News yesterday, Packham (pictured) said it was what he called ‘driven grouse shooting’ the sport of shooting red grouse, that he wants banned

A member of a shooting party takes his aim on a moor near Ripon, North Yorkshire, as the Glorious Twelfth marks the start of the shooting season on Monday

A member of a shooting party takes his aim on a moor near Ripon, North Yorkshire, as the Glorious Twelfth marks the start of the shooting season on Monday

Members of a shooting party across the moorland. The team of shooters line out a numbered pegs while a group of beaters and their dogs move through the areas flushing the game ahead of them

Members of a shooting party across the moorland. The team of shooters line out a numbered pegs while a group of beaters and their dogs move through the areas flushing the game ahead of them

‘Perhaps more disturbingly than the vast quantities of animals being killed, is the profound lack of fundamental, ecological knowledge in the fraternity of people who currently have custodianship over this part of our landscape.

‘They simply don’t understand how conservation works. 

‘We are looking at the widespread slaughter of millions of animals, legally and the continued persecution of other birds.’

He added: ‘To call driven grouse shooting in any way an advantage to conservation is frankly hysterical.’

The call by Labour threatens to put the party on a collision course with landowners who argue that shooting creates valuable employment opportunities while helping to protect the environment.

A golden retriever holds a brace of grouse in its mouth on a moor near Ripon, North Yorkshire, on Monday as the season commences

A golden retriever holds a brace of grouse in its mouth on a moor near Ripon, North Yorkshire, on Monday as the season commences

Head keeper Mark Palmer with Paddy the dog at the Rottal Estate in Glen Clova, near Kirriemuir, Angus, Scotland, on the 'Glorious Twelfth'

Head keeper Mark Palmer with Paddy the dog at the Rottal Estate in Glen Clova, near Kirriemuir, Angus, Scotland, on the ‘Glorious Twelfth’

Countryside groups yesterday dismissed Labour’s calls for a review of grouse shooting as a ‘thinly veiled political attack’.

Countryside Alliance has said it was ‘extraordinary’ that Labour had launched a ‘thinly veiled political attack on grouse shooting’ during ‘the present political turmoil’.

It added an independent review would be welcomed as it would highlight the benefits of shooting.

Adrian Blackmore, the Countryside Alliance’s director of shooting, said: ‘Those with any knowledge of grouse shooting and its associated management will know some of the claims being made by Labour are nonsense. 

A grouse on a moor near Ripon, North Yorkshire, swoops above the moorland at the start of the shooting season

A grouse on a moor near Ripon, North Yorkshire, swoops above the moorland at the start of the shooting season

‘If an independent review would help increase Labour’s understanding of its considerable environmental, economic and social benefits, then it should be welcomed.’

Grouse shooting has been cancelled at Balmoral this year due to a fall in bird numbers.

Shooting grouse is relished by the royal family on their summer holidays at Balmoral but heavy snowfall at the end of last year – followed by a dry and humid start to this summer – has reduced game bird breeding.

An estate source said: ‘Grouse numbers go up and down but this year they have plummeted.

Robin Leslie-Melville a member of the shooting party in Scotland takes his aim on the moorland as others form a line across the land

Robin Leslie-Melville a member of the shooting party in Scotland takes his aim on the moorland as others form a line across the land

‘There probably will be no grouse shooting on Balmoral this season. It’s very disappointing.’

Grouse moors cover around 550,000 acres of land in in England and Scotland.

However, Labour said that the process of draining the land in preparation for the shooting season destroyed ‘huge swathes’ of plant life while also killing large numbers of animals.

Moors were often burned, increasing the likelihood of both wildfires and flooding while increasing carbon emissions and dramatically reducing their future capacity to absorb carbon.

At the same time, the party said that species such hen harriers – which feed on grouse chicks – and mountain hares were often illegally culled.

But despite such damage, Labour said that the 10 largest English grouse moors received a total of £3 million in annual farm subsidies.

Shadow environment secretary Sue Hayman said: ‘The costs of grouse shooting on our environment and wildlife needs to be to properly weighed up against the benefit of land owners profiting from shooting parties.

‘For too long the Tories have bent the knee to land owners and it’s our environment and our people who pay the price.

‘There are viable alternatives to grouse shooting such as simulated shooting and wildlife tourism. The time has come for a proper review into the practice.’

However Duncan Thomas, a regional director at the British Association for Shooting and Conservation, said he was confident any review would demonstrate the benefits of a well-run grouse moor.

‘Grouse moors are bio-diverse and the shoots they support create vital employment in isolated rural areas supporting communities,’ he told The Daily Telegraph.

‘Effective heather management including burning and cutting creates amazing habitat and of course reduces the fuel load and risk of wildfire.’

Officials said that protecting the moorland environment was a ‘priority’ for the Government, as was the protection of the hen harrier.

The birds were protected from illegal killing under the Wildlife and Countryside Act and the Government had strong penalties in place for offences committed against birds of prey.

Ministers were said to be continuing to work closely with landowners, tenant farmers and sporting interests to sign up to voluntary agreements, including a commitment to stop the rotational burning of heather on bog land.

Let’s block ads! (Why?)

Distinct Today is a news media company, focused on the intersection between hyper-relevant content and digital innovation. Distinct Today curates editorial news content, experiences, and events across multiple platforms including email, mobile, online and offline. Distinct Today is headquartered in Houston, Texas. The company is privately held. Distinct Today targets an affluent, college-educated audience.